Economic Policy Ministry of Finance publications – 2019:5 Budget review 2019 January 2019 Table of Contents 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 2 Economic outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 3 Government economic policy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 4 Sustainable development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 5 Budget 2019 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 7 Inquiries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 8 Reading instructions and printable version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 2 1 Introduction General government finances in Finland con- sist of central government, local government and social security funds. Central government finances consist of on-budget activities and off-budget activities (the off-budget activities are discussed in chapter 9 ”Extra-budgetary central government finances” of the budget). The position of central government on-bud- get activities in central government finances and general government finances is illustrated by Diagram 1. This publication is mainly con- cerned with the central government on-bud- get activities. It examines the Government’s 2019 budget, which was approved by Parlia- ment in December 2018. The purpose is to provide a concise description of the main the- mes of the budget with the help of diagrams and tables as well as to guide the reader to explore the themes in more detail via Inter- net links. The background materials for bud- geting include the independent economic fo- recasts produced by the Economics Depart- ment at the Ministry of Finance, which are presented in the Economic Survey. The central government budget is a plan con- cerned with the central government’s finan- ces and financial management prepared on the basis of the General Government Fiscal Plan published in the spring. In practice, the budget evaluates the extent and allocation of central government revenue and expenditure for the following year. The Government nego- tiates on the budget proposal in the budget session. In Finland, the Parliament has the prime de- cision-making authority on the use of central government resources. The Parliament pri- marily exercises its power in two ways: by enacting laws and approving budgets. The majority of the content of the budget is bound by law and, indeed, laws are often amended before making decisions on the bud- get. The Parliament approves the budget for the following budget year before the end of the previous budget year. The Government Programme defines the Go- vernment’s main economic policies, which serve as the basis for preparing the budget. At the beginning of the parliamentary term, the Government also decides on the spen- ding limits for the parliamentary term, i.e. the central government’s expenditure ceiling, and the rules for the spending limits procedu- re. At the same time, the spending limits set the outline for the entire expenditure during the four-year parliamentary term. The spen- ding limits’ allocation for each administrative branch is reviewed within the parliamentary term spending limits in April as part of the General Government Fiscal Plan, and upda- tes the spending limits to correspond to chan- ges to the level of costs, prices and spending limit expenditure structure. For more infor- mation, see http://vm.fi/en/central-govern- ment-spending-limits. 3 The 2019 budget amounts to EUR 55.5 billi- on. Most of the appropriations will be spent on social security. Revenue will be primari- ly collected in taxes based on turnover, such as value-added tax, and income taxes, inclu- ding earned income and capital income tax. The central government on-budget deficit is predicted to amount to EUR 1.7 billion and central government debt is expected to rise to approximately EUR 107 billion. The following chapter includes an overview of the economic outlook in the areas of real economy and general government finances. Chapter 3 is concerned with the Govern- ment’s economic policy goals and their imp- lementation. Chapter 4 examines the budget from a sustainable development perspective. Chapter 5 includes the 2019 budget’s reve- nue and expenditure estimates, deficit and debt. Local government and regional finan- ces are also discussed from the viewpoint of the on-budget activities. Chapter 6 includes a summary of the review. 4 2 Economic outlook The economic review of the Ministry of Fi- nance deals with the economic outlook at the national and international level as well as economic policy and general government finance. Real economy In the global economy the fastest growth phase of the current cycle has already passed, and so growth will slow down over the coming years. In 2019, the growth in Finland’s econ- omy will slow to 1.5%. The slowdown will be broad-based, but growth will be particularly affected by a decline in housing investment. Export growth in 2019 will be impeded by the erection of further trade barriers. Never- theless, net exports, aided by an increase in capacity in the forest industry, will continue to support GDP growth. The rapid rise in households’ disposable income will continue as the growth in earnings gathers pace. In 2019, real income will grow significantly and household consumption growth will quicken in comparison with the previous year, despite rising inflation. Although GDP will be slow- ing, the emergence of only a moderate rise in real wages and salaries will ensure that the demand for labour is maintained in 2019. The unemployment rate is projected to fall to 6.9% and the employment rate to rise to 72.4% in 2019. Key forecast figures for 2016–2019 have been compiled in Table 1. General government finances The growth in the economy and the measures to curb rising expenditure are strengthening general government finances. Still consider- ably in deficit just a few years ago, Finland’s general government finances will be in bal- ance at the end of the present decade. The government-debt-to-GDP ratio will also fall in the coming years. General government finances will neverthe- less begin to gradually weaken in the early part of the 2020s when GDP growth slows and the annual consolidation measures being made in the current government term come to an end. The ageing of the population will weaken general government finances, as this will increase the expenditure on pensions and health and care services year by year. Indeed, the ageing of the population will create con- siderable pressure on general government fi- nances in the long term. Table 2 presents key 5 indicators for general government finances for 2016–2019. In addition to economic cycles, the structures of general government finances are also re- flected on the revenue contributions to gen- eral government and the allocation of expen- diture. Diagram 2 illustrates that the major- ity of general government revenue was col- lected as income or wealth tax, and as indi- rect tax, in 2016. Most of general government expenditure con- sists of expenditure on social security bene- fits, as shown in Diagram 3. This expendi- ture includes pensions, unemployment ben- efits, benefits aimed at families as well as housing allowance, allowances during illness and allowances preventing social exclusion. Table 3 illustrates the average extent of the costs resulting from education and culture as well as social welfare and health care ser- vices. The table reveals, for example, that the costs per student of vocational educa- tion and training were the highest compared with other forms of education in 2016. 6 3 Government economic policy Prime Minister Sipilä’s Government de- cided on its economic policy in the Government Programme (http://val- tioneuvosto.fi/en/sipila/government-pro- gramme). The Government’s objective is to raise Finland’s economy on to a path of sustainable growth and rising employment, and to secure the funding of public services and social security. The objective is for the increase in general government debt ratio to GDP to level off by t he e nd o f the parliamentary term and to bring living on debt to an end in 2021. In addition to fiscal p olicy o bjectives, the Government has set as targets that the em- ployment rate will rise to 72% and the num- ber of people in employment by 110,000 dur- ing the parliamentary term. In the light of current forecasts, these employment targets are being met. The achievement of the ob- jectives has been facilitated by the good eco- nomic climate. The rapid growth in em- ployment has increased tax revenue and the decline in unemployment has reduced unem- ployment expenditure. The Government has supported the sustain- able growth of the economy and employment through structural reforms. Efforts have been made to increase demand for labour with the Competitiveness Pact, which entered into ef- fect in 2017 and has improved the compet- itiveness of Finnish businesses. Supply of labour, on the other hand, has been boosted by, for example, removing incentive traps, in- creasing labour mobility and reforming the unemployment benefit s ystem a nd employ- ment services. At the same time, the Gov- ernment has adhered to the Government Pro- gramme policy of not increasing the taxation of wage earners. A cornerstone of the Government’s economic policy is bridging the sustainability gap. At the beginning of the parliamentary term, the sustainability gap was estimated to be ap- proximately EUR 10 billion at 2019 prices. The immediate consolidation measures in ac- cordance with the Government Programme have been recorded in the central government spending limits and are for 2019 included in the budget. The immediate consolidation measures account for approximately EUR 4 billion of the EUR 10 billion package of mea- sures, although there remains uncertainty as- sociated with the impact of measures depen- dent on decisions by municipalities and with the impact assessments of certain measures. The regional government, health and social services reform as well as other measures to reform public administration may, if success- ful, strengthen general government finances by EUR 4 billion in the long term. In addition to the debt target, the Govern- ment has set targets for the general govern- ment budgetary position related, on the one hand, to the budgetary position of central government, local government and the so- cial security funds during the parliamentary term and, on the other hand, to the com- bined structural budgetary position of gen- eral government in the medium term. Table 4 describes these objectives and rules that guide Finland’s fiscal policy targets, and com- pares them with the forecast by the Min- istry of Finance. In the light of the forecast, 7 the sector-specific budgetary objectives for general government finances will be broadly achieved. Local government and the social security funds will achieve the objectives set for them, and central government will more or less reach the objective set for it. Finland’s general government fiscal targets are also governed by EU regulations, most significant of which is the Stability and Growth Pact, which requires that Member States maintain structural balance in gen- eral government finances and avoid excessive debt. 8 4 Sustainable development The global 2030 Agenda for Sustainable De- velopment was adopted at the UN Summit in 2015. It sets common goals for sustai- nable development for all UN member sta- tes. The Government has prepared a report on the implementation of the 2030 Agenda, outlining the key focus areas and actions for enhancing sustainable development in Fin- land economically, socially and environmen- tally. The Government’s national implemen- tation of the 2030 Agenda is based on two focus areas: A carbon-neutral and resource- wise Finland and A non-discriminating, equ- al and competent Finland. Chapter 6 of the budget’s general strategy and outlook focu- ses on sustainable development. 4.1 Appropriations In connection with the preparation of the 2019 budget, the appropriations included in the budget that promote the goals of the fo- cus area A carbon-neutral and resource-wise Finland have been identified. The said app- ropriations are presented in Tables 5-7 and they are broken down according to the key actions of the above-mentioned report. The identified appropriations will promote, among other things, biodiversity and the wellbeing of the environment and nature, reduce emis- sions, advance bioeconomy solutions and de- velop Finland towards a low-carbon society. The identified appropriations can be found, in particular, in the administrative branches of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Emp- loyment, the Ministry of Agriculture and Fo- restry, the Ministry of Transport and Com- munications, the Ministry of the Environment and the Ministry for Foreign Affairs. 9 The goals of the carbon-neutral and resour- ce-wise Finland focus area will be promoted with a total of approximately EUR 1.7 billion in the 2019 budget. This represents a decre- ase of approximately EUR 126 million from 2018, mainly due to the termination of Go- vernment key projects at the end of 2018. In addition, the amount of support for rene- wable energy has been reduced as a result of the higher than expected market price of electricity and the increased tax on peat. The Government that takes office after the 2019 parliamentary elections will decide on possib- le changes in the appropriation levels. The largest package of measures is the crea- tion of bioeconomy and cleantech solutions, presented in Table 6, for which EUR 702.6 million is allocated for 2019. Of this, the lar- gest share, EUR 290.7 million, consists of en- vironmental compensation, organic producti- on, advice and non-productive investments. In addition, a significant package of measu- res, presented in Table 5, is the implementa- tion of the energy and climate strategy and the medium-term climate policy, for which a total of EUR 458.7 million is allocated. Of this sum, EUR 214.5 million is allocated to the production subsidy for renewable energy. Other significant individual appropriation items include the purchase and development of public transport services (EUR 87.5 milli- on), funding for regional and local rural deve- lopment (EUR 107 million), greening support (EUR 157.5 million), support for sustainable development research, development and in- novation (EUR 121.2 million) and develop- ment cooperation projects, which will promo- te, for example, food security and sustainable use of natural resources (EUR 159 million). 4.2 Taxes The 2019 budget includes a number of ta- xes that may be considered as promoting the carbon-neutral and resource-wise Finland fo- cus area. These include, in particular, energy taxes, motor vehicle tax, car tax, excise du- ty on certain beverage packagings and waste tax. Although these taxes may be regarded as meeting sustainable development objectives, they may also include individual tax struc- tures that are both in accordance with and contrary to the objectives. Energy taxes are collected on transport fu- els, off-road work machine and heating fuels, and electricity. In addition to the tax revenue 10 they raise, energy taxes boost incentives for energy-efficiency and lower-emission energy production. Diagram 5 illustrates the deve- lopment of the tax levels of various fuels and electricity from 2009 to 2018. The diagram shows that the tax levels of fuels and elect- ricity have risen gradually since 2011, exclu- ding the tax on peat, which has risen and fallen during the period. In 2011, the natio- nal energy tax system was reformed such that the litre- or weight-based excise duty on fuel was changed to an energy content tax, ba- sed on the energy content of a fuel, and to a carbon dioxide tax, based on the specific emissions of carbon dioxide arising from the combustion of a fuel. Local emissions arising from the combustion of fuels also began to be taken into account in the calculation cri- teria for the tax. The 2019 budget makes changes to energy taxes that can be considered as contributing to the objectives of the carbon-neutral and resource-wise Finland focus area. The emissi- ons steering of combined electricity and heat production will be increased. Taxation of off- road work machine and heating fuels will be increased and changed such that, in calcu- lating the carbon dioxide tax of a fuel, ot- her greenhouse gas emissions arising during the fuel’s life cycle will also be taken into ac- count in addition to the greenhouse gas emis- sions arising from the combustion of the fuel. Details of the 2019 tax changes are not yet known in all respects, but the tax level will rise from 2018. Motor vehicle tax and car tax are determined partly on an emissions basis, so they increase the cost of acquiring and running larger-emis- sion vehicles and therefore encourage a shift towards lower-emission transport. The excise duty on certain beverage packagings encou- rages recycling of beverage packagings. The waste tax, on the other hand, is a steering environmental tax aimed at reducing landfill processing of waste and increasing recycling. The car tax emission scale has been steepe- ned during this parliamentary term and the latest tax reduction for low-emission cars en- tered into force at the beginning of 2019. The reduction of the motor vehicle tax for tax days beyond the start of 2020 will reduce motor vehicle tax receipts already in 2019. The tax reduction also brings a slight tigh- tening of the motor vehicle tax emission sca- le, but the emissions-increasing impact of the lower tax may in fact be exacerbated by the tax reduction’s cost-cutting effect on car use. The overall impact on carbon dioxide emissi- ons from transport will, however, be minor. 4.3 Environmentally harmful subsidies Environmentally harmful subsidies refer to subsidies that result in an increase in the utilisation of natural resources and the en- vironmental burden in the subsidised enterp- rise or the subsidised sector. The introducti- on of these subsidies is generally justified on non-environmental grounds, as they may also have positive effects on other policy objecti- ves such as food production, regional econo- my, employment and growth. These positive impacts should be taken into account in eva- 11 luating the subsidies. The 2019 budget includes environmentally harmful subsidies, which can be identified particularly in the tax system but also in appropriations. The environmentally harmful subsidies discussed in this context are based on studies conducted earlier. (Environmental impact of subsidies in the sector of the Mi- nistry of Agriculture and Forestry, 2012; En- vironmentally harmful subsidies, 2013; Pre- paration of the structural policy programme, 2013; Subsidies harmful to biodiversity, 2015. [All in Finnish]) The tax system includes tax subsidies, i.e. exemptions from the normal tax structure. The largest environmentally harmful tax sub- sidies are in the field of energy taxation, na- mely the lower than normal tax rates for die- sel, off-road work machines, peat, industry and greenhouses, the tax refund for energy- intensive companies and the energy tax re- fund for agriculture. In the appropriations, compensation for indirect costs of emissions trading and certain agricultural subsidies, for example, can be classified as environmentally harmful subsidies. Based on the above-mentioned studies, the environmentally harmful subsidies in the 2019 budget are estimated to amount to approxi- mately EUR 3.5 billion, which mainly con- sist of various tax subsidies. Environmentally harmful subsidies are mainly directed at th- ree sectors: energy, transport and agriculture. The transport sector is the largest of these, estimated at approximately EUR 1.4 billion, but the subsidy levels of the sectors are quite close to each other. In both the energy and agriculture sectors, the subsidies amount to slightly over EUR 1 billion. The largest single environmental harmful subsidy consists of the lower electricity tax rate for industry and greenhouses, and it is estimated to amount to approximately EUR 600 million in 2019. In the transport sector, the subsidy levels of the lower tax rate on die- sel, the commuting expenses deduction and the lower tax rate on light fuel oil used in off- road work machines are all close to approxi- mately EUR 400 million. In the agriculture sector, the largest single subsidy consists of the payments for least favoured areas, which balances the effects of differences in natu- ral conditions and amounts to approximately EUR 548 million. 12 5 Budget 2019 Central government revenue and expenditure are examined in the budget’s general general strategy and outlook in chapters 4 and 5 as well as in the detailed rationale (www.bud- jetti.vm.fi, in Finnish or Swedish). The rev- enue estimates are presented by department and the appropriation estimates by adminis- trative branch. 5.1 Revenue, expenditure, deficit and debt Revenue In 2019, central government on-budget rev- enue (excluding net borrowing) is estimated to be approximately EUR 53.8 billion, with tax revenue accounting for approximately 85%, i.e. EUR 45.8 billion. Tax revenue is expected to grow by 3.7% in 2019. Diagram 6 examines the development of tax revenue between 2005 and 2019. The recov- ery in economic growth that began in 2016 has boosted growth in tax revenue. Value- added tax is the central government’s largest single source of revenue. During the current economic upswing, corporate tax revenue has grown most strongly. Growth in energy tax receipts, on the other hand, has remained subdued despite an increase in taxation. Expenditure The appropriations of the budget amount to EUR 55.5 billion, which is approximately EUR 0.3 billion less than in the actual 2018 budget. The expenditure level is reduced by the ending of fixed-term key projects, the consolidation measures in accordance with Annex 6 of the Government Programme, and lower unemployment benefit expenditure due to the improved employment situation. The savings impact of a number of consolidation measures, such as measures related to ba- sic transport infrastructure, regional develop- ment of specialised medical care and operat- ing expenditure, will grow in 2019. The im- pact of consolidation measures in accordance with Annex 6 of the Government Programme will reduce central government expenditure by approximately EUR 0.3 billion from 2018. In addition, the freezing of index adjustments is a factor that improves the budget balance. The expenditure level is raised by, among 13 other things, statutory and contractual in- creases, such as pay rises in accordance with the central government collective agreement concluded in the spring, and certain auto- matic factors, such as growth in age-related central government pension expenditure. The allocation of appropriations, i.e. central government expenditure, to different pur- poses depends on political decisions, eco- nomic structures and economic cycles. In 2019, a significant share of the budget ap- propriations will be allocated to social secu- rity (36%). Diagram 7 illustrates where the Finnish State will allocate its appropriations in 2019. Part of the revenue in the central govern- ment budget is received from the European Union, while Finland also pays contributions to the EU. At central government level, Fin- land is projected to contribute approximately EUR 2.1 billion to the EU budget and the European Development Fund in 2019. Fin- land’s contributions will be EUR 205 million higher than the figure budgeted for 2018. Finland is expected to receive revenue of ap- proximately EUR 1.2 billion from the EU bud- get, which is EUR 187 million more than the projected figure for 2018. The relationship between EU revenue and expenditure in the central government finances is illustrated in Table 8. In accordance with the budget pro- posal of the EU for 2019, EU funding will be allocated to addressing challenges related to migration and the situation with refugees, improving the security of the citizens of EU Member States, and additional contributions related to strategic investments and sustain- able growth. Deficit The 2019 budget shows a deficit of approxi- mately EUR 1.7 billion, which will be covered by increased borrowing. The deficit will in- crease slightly compared with the figure bud- geted for 2018, taking into account the ap- proved supplementary budgets. The budget deficit for 2018 will be reduced by early repay- ment to the central government of refinanc- ing credits. Without these premature repay- ments, the budget deficit for 2018 would be an estimated EUR 2.7 billion. In national accounting terms, the central government deficit for 2019 is expected to be approximately 0.7% in ratio to GDP. Central government on-budget activities have shown a deficit since 2009. The situation is illus- trated in Diagram 8. 14 Debt At the end of 2019, central government debt (including debt of off-budget entities) is es- timated to be approximately EUR 107 bil- lion, which is approximately 44% of GDP. The lower than budgeted net borrowing in 2018 had the effect of reducing the level of debt. Diagram 9 illustrates that central gov- ernment debt has more or less doubled over the last ten years. 5.2 Excerpts from tax and allocation decisions in the 2019 budget TAX CRITERIA CHANGE Most of the tax criteria changes under the Government Programme have already been implemented in 2016–2018. Key measures have been a reduction in taxation on labour and an increase in excise duty and real-estate tax taxation. In 2019, the gradual entry into force of changes according to the Government Pro- gramme will continue: the tobacco tax will be tightened, the car tax will be eased and the deduction for interest paid on housing loans will be reduced. The taxation of earned income will be re- duced, with the emphasis on low-income earners, by raising the low-income allowance, the earned income deduction and the pension income allowances in central and local taxa- tion. The combined effect of this annually, covering all tax recipients, will be EUR 130 million. In addition, an index adjustment will be made to the earned income taxation crite- ria to ensure that there is no increase in tax- ation arising from movements in the general earnings level. The existence of a reduced lower limit at which the so-called solidarity tax is paid will continue in 2019. The maximum amount of the deduction for temporary quarters will be raised so it better supports moving for the sake of work. The tax exempt mileage allowance payable to vol- untary workers will be broadened. In accor- dance with the Government Programme, mu- nicipalities will be compensated for the rev- enue impact of changes in tax criteria. The restriction of companies’ right to deduct in- terest will be tightened when Finland imple- ments the EU’s Tax Evasion Directive. Excise duties will be increased to compensate for the tax revenue losses resulting from the easing of earned income taxation. The excise duty on alcohol will be increased by an annual EUR 30 million and the excise duty on soft drinks by an annual EUR 25 million. Taxa- tion of heating fuels will be changed so that 15 the calculation of a fuel’s carbon dioxide tax will take into account the average life cycle emissions of the fuel. In addition, the tax on peat will be increased and the tax subsidy for combined electricity and heat production will be changed so that the halving of the carbon dioxide tax is replaced by a reduction in the energy content tax. As a result, tax revenue from peat and other heating fuels will rise in gross terms by EUR 38 million. The motor vehicle tax will be reduced by EUR 50 million for tax days beyond the start of 2020, which will reduce tax receipts already in 2019. GENERAL PUBLIC SERVICES incl. Foreign Service An appropriation of EUR 60 million is allo- cated to the Prime Minister’s Office in 2019 for the preparation and implementation of the Presidency of the Council of the Euro- pean Union. Finland will hold the Presidency of the Council of the European Union from 1 July to 31 December 2019. A sum of EUR 860,000 is allocated in 2019 for the Healthy Premises 2028 Programme. The programme aims to make public build- ings healthy and improve healthcare and re- habilitation for those suffering from poor in- door air quality. An appropriation of EUR 1.5 million is allo- cated for the Sami truth and reconciliation process. An increase of EUR 7 million in election ex- penditure is allocated for the holding of the 2019 county elections in connection with the European Parliament elections. A total of EUR 17.6 million is allocated for the Foreign Service’s construction projects, of which EUR 7 million is for temporary premises for the secretariat of the Embassy of Finland in Beijing and EUR 4.3 million for renovation of the premises of the Embassy of Finland in Moscow. In addition, an increase of EUR 1.2 million is allocated for the Foreign Service for the reopening of the diplomatic mission in Baghdad. An increase is made in the budget author- ity for commitment to replacing European Investment Bank capital, allowing Finland’s share of the EIB’s subscribed capital to be raised by EUR 595 million to a total of EUR 3.694 billion, from the present EUR 3.099 bil- lion, due to the United Kingdom’s withdrawal from the European Union. An appropriation of EUR 211 million is allo- cated for the preparation of the regional gov- ernment, health and social services reform, i.e. for county and interim administration costs, change management, the development and modification of information systems and information management, and the establish- ment and operation of the counties’ joint ser- vice centres. Of the central government transfer to local government for basic public services, EUR 30 million will be allocated to promote dig- italisation in local government. In addition, EUR 10 million will be allocated to the discre- tionary increase in central government trans- fers to local government. 16 DEFENCE A EUR 9.8 million increase is allocated in De- fence Forces appropriations for additional ex- penditure resulting from the implementation of the Military Intelligence Act and an ad- ditional EUR 5.8 million for increasing the number of personnel. A sum of EUR 260 million is allocated for de- fence materiel procurement for the first year’s financial contribution to the Squadron 2020 Project. An additional EUR 1.5 million is allocated for military crisis management, materiel and ad- ministration expenditure compared to the ac- tual budget for 2018. The increase is mainly due to the planned continuation of the Iraq OIR and Afghanistan RS operations. PUBLIC ORDER AND SAFETY An increase of approximately EUR 18 million is made in Police appropriations to safeguard core operations. The aim of the funding is, among other things, to maintain the num- ber of police at the current level, namely ap- proximately 7,200. In addition, an increase of EUR 2.5 million is made for community police activities, EUR 2.2 million is allocated for the costs of establishing a reserve police system, and EUR 3.3 million to increase the number of police in sparsely settled areas in partic- ular. The police are also allocated other in- creases, for example for the Government ICT Centre’s TUVE service costs and for moni- toring of aliens. An additional appropriation of EUR 10 mil- lion is allocated to the Finnish Security Intel- ligence Service for expenditure arising from civilian intelligence legislation, provided that the legislation enters into force in 2019. In addition, the Finnish Security Intelligence Service is allocated additional funding of EUR 2.5 million to secure its core activities and operational capacity, and EUR 1.6 million for premises project costs. A total of approximately EUR 2 million is al- located to the police, the Ministry of the Inte- rior, the Regional State Administrative Agen- cies and others for the costs related to the legislation that has come into force on the monitoring of money laundering. An additional appropriation of EUR 2.8 mil- lion is allocated in Border Guard appropria- tions for increased resource needs resulting from the growth of external border traffic at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport, and an increase of EUR 2 million is allocated to secure core op- erations. Rescue services are allocated an additional EUR 0.9 million, of which EUR 0.5 million is for the training of emergency response centre operators. Expenditure relating to asylum seekers will decline from 2018 by EUR 25 million. An estimate of 4,000 asylum seekers per year has been used as the assumption for immi- gration expenditure. Approximately 10,500 people are estimated to be within the scope of reception. The number of quota refugees will remain unchanged at 750 people. Financial and debt counselling duties will be transferred to the state legal aid offices from the beginning of 2019. A total of EUR 8 million will be allocated to improving the po- sition of over-indebted individuals. This will be directed at, among other things, financial and debt counselling, counselling of indebted individuals in connection with debt enforce- ment, and speeding up court proceedings. Additional funding totalling EUR 1.8 mil- 17 lion is allocated for the Criminal Sanctions Agency to enhance sanctions ancillary to con- ditional imprisonment and to reduce the re- cidivism risk of those convicted of violent of- fences. ISSUES RELATED TO BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY An increase of EUR 10.3 million is allocated for Employment and Economic Development Offices to support active job seeking and im- prove services for jobseekers, and an addi- tional EUR 10 million to arrange regular in- terviews. The maximum number of people on the wage subsidy payable to for example asso- ciations and foundations is raised from 3,000 to 4,000. The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Em- ployment is allocated approval authority of EUR 23 million for the recompense payable on employment provision results during the period 2020−2024. This allows commitment to the employment impact investment fund project aimed at reducing long-term unem- ployment. Performance-based remuneration is based on the effectiveness of actions, which is ascertained by comparing the project par- ticipants with an equivalent control group of other unemployed people. Business Finland’s authorisation to make grants amounts to EUR 344.4 million, which is EUR 73.6 million more than in the actual budget for 2018. An increase of EUR 8 mil- lion is allocated for the operating expendi- ture of Business Finland innovation funding agency, to be allocated to programme activ- ities and to strengthen operations abroad. An additional EUR 1 million is allocated for the Geological Survey of Finland to explore battery mineral reserves and the potential for strengthening the domestic battery clus- ter. Funding for the VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland is increased by a total of EUR 10.4 million for the costs of the de- commissioning of the FiR1 research reactor and the refurbishment of the Otakaari 3 hot cell facilities, and EUR 7 million for boosting strategic research. EUR 3 million is allocated for rapidly imple- mentable projects supporting the availability of skilled labour in regional cities, where the surrounding municipalities and businesses are also willing to make a contribution to financ- ing the projects. The authority to grant energy subsidies is in- creased by EUR 25 million. A further EUR 10 million is allocated for ship- building innovation support, which will en- able the shipbuilding industry to invest in in- novation and in enhancing its global compet- itiveness. The scrapping premium and support for the purchase of electric cars as well as gas and ethanol conversions of cars will be continued, and a total of EUR 6 million is allocated for this purpose. An increase of EUR 40.3 million will be allo- cated to basic transport infrastructure man- agement, for example to reduce the repair defecit and improve transport safety. In ad- dition, an increase of EUR 4 million is allo- cated to grants for the maintenance of im- provement of private roads. A sum of EUR 3.5 million is allocated to the discretionary government transfers for pro- moting walking and cycling and for public transport projects in local government. 18 A number of appropriation increases are made for supporting agriculture, to ease the profitability problems of agriculture due to for example drought in the 2018 growing season. A EUR 27.5 million increase is allocated in 2019 for payments to least favoured areas. An increase of EUR 22.5 million is allocated for safeguarding the operating conditions for agriculture. In addition, an increase of EUR 4 million is allocated to national aid for agricul- ture and horticulture, for use in meeting the need to adjust aid and support levels in situ- ations where the use of aid has exceeded the projected level. In 2019 EUR 20 million will be paid with regard to the raised refund of energy taxes on agriculture paid in 2018. A sum of EUR 3 million will be allocated to the Farmers’ Pension Institute (MELA) for 2019– 2020 to continue the Välitä viljelijästä (Con- sideration for farmers) project. Additional in- vestments are also to be made, for example to promote bioeconomy innovation, for food exports and to improve farm structure. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION A sum of EUR 15 million is allocated for the implementation of a new waterways protec- tion enhancement programme. For companies committed to the Green Deal agreement currently being prepared, oil waste charges on restoration and develop- ment projects related to oil waste manage- ment will apply on a temporary basis. The implementation of the Forest Biodi- versity Programme for Southern Finland (METSO) will continue. In addition, EUR 0.2 million is allocated for updated invento- ries of traditional rural biotopes. Closure ac- tivities in the area of the Hitura mine, located in Nivala, will continue and EUR 16.3 million is allocated for this purpose. An additional EUR 3.7 million is allocated to Metsähallitus, for instance for developing na- tional parks and nature conservation areas. HOUSING AND COMMUNITY SER- VICES A sum of EUR 50 million from National Hous- ing Fund resources can be used for the cap- italisation of A-Kruunu Oy, which will facili- tate an increase in construction. EUR 400,000 is allocated to the Housing Fi- nance and Development Centre of Finland for the launch of an experimentation project on living in housing cooperatives. HEALTHCARE An increase of EUR 8.8 million will be made in central government funding for university- level research in healthcare units. The influenza vaccine programme will be de- veloped and expanded so that the vaccine is offered in the future to children aged from six months to six years. An increase of EUR 1 million is allocated to acquire the vaccines. EUR 1.2 million is allocated for the continua- 19 tion and expansion of the pilot schemes con- cerning the development of national quality registers for healthcare. RECREATION AND CULTURE The Schools on the Move programme will be extended to upper secondary school students, for which a total of EUR 2.8 million is allo- cated in 2019. To strengthen prerequisites for top-level sport, the central government will prepare for the capitalisation of an Olympic Fund, which will be established by transferring to it a maximum of EUR 20 million of state- owned share assets. The central government capitalisation will be made in proportion to private capital provided. EUR 1 million is allocated for the launching of pilot schemes promoting physical exercise among children in early childhood education and care. The libraries’ digital project is allocated EUR 860,000 for personnel skills development and for consolidating the AUTA Project operating model. EDUCATION As part of Government measures to promote skills, research and growth, the grant autho- risations of the Academy of Finland for sci- entific research is raised by EUR 25 million. An additional appropriation of EUR 5 mil- lion annually is allocated to strengthening the R&D&I activities of the universities of ap- plied sciences. The Ministry of Education and Culture is granted authority under which the central government may transfer EUR 60 million in listed shares to the basic capital of the re- search-supporting foundation set up by the central government, and EUR 80 million in listed shares to the equity of the limited liabil- ity company to be set up to promote educa- tion exports and the development of learning environments in vocational education. A sum of EUR 10 million is allocated for the implementation of the new Act on General Upper Secondary Education and for devel- opment of the quality of general upper sec- ondary education. Implementation of the re- form of upper secondary education will be launched by removing restrictions on the re- sitting of the matriculation examination, for which EUR 0.4 million is allocated. The implementation of the reform of voca- tional education and training will continue and will be further supported by funding of EUR 15 million. An additional EUR 2 million is allocated for promoting educational equality and the qual- ity of education in pre-primary and compre- hensive school education. In addition, EUR 3 million is allocated to supporting traditional club activities in schools. Equality and raising the participation rate in early childhood education will be enhanced and an appropriation of EUR 10 million for positive discrimination grants is allocated for organisers of early childhood education. The pilot project on free early childhood edu- cation for five-year-olds will be expanded, and an additional appropriation of EUR 5 million is allocated for this purpose. An increase of approximately EUR 8 million is allocated in expenditure on financial aid for students for extending the right to financial aid for students to primary and lower sec- 20 ondary education students who have passed the age of compulsory schooling, for a learn- ing materials allowance for general upper sec- ondary education and vocational education students, and for extending the academic year support period in general upper sec- ondary education. From the start of 2019, scholarships received by students will not be counted as income. From 1 August 2019, in the case of students aged less than 18, study grants and housing supplement will not be reduced on the basis of parental income. To meet these changes, an additional EUR 930,000 is allocated to study grant expendi- ture. SOCIAL SECURITY incl. earnings- related pensions Due to the growing volume of pension ex- penditure and related index adjustments, an increase of EUR 115 million on the previous year is allocated for pensions and compen- sation paid by the central government. An additional EUR 17.1 million is allocated for the central government’s share of the expen- diture on self-employed persons’ pensions, as the amount of insurance contributions will be below the level anticipated. It is expected that unemployment benefit ex- penditure will decline by approximately EUR 292 million, mainly due to a fall in the un- employment rate. On the other hand, a total increase of EUR 3.4 million is allocated for unemployment security expenditure as a re- sult of the shortening of the period without benefit, from 90 to 60 days. Further efforts will be made to boost employment by allocat- ing EUR 20 million to improving incentives to accept work. In addition, the realisation of the right to earnings-related unemployment benefit for family members of entrepreneurs will be promoted, for which EUR 10 million is allocated. It is proposed that the scope of the pension subsidy be expanded to cover new age co- horts. People who have been unemployed for over five years and are aged 60 or more could receive the subsidy if they so wish. A net ap- propriation of approximately EUR 3 million is allocated for the pension subsidy. An increase of just under EUR 15 million is allocated for Kela’s social security funds, to be allocated for instance to operating costs arising from the implementation of the acti- vation model for unemployment benefit and from the work associated with decisions on social assistance. The status of adoptive and multiple-birth families will be improved. A sum of EUR 300,000 is allocated for adjusting the adop- tion grant for families adopting from abroad, and the paternity allowance period for fathers in multiple-birth families will be extended. The levels of the smallest daily allowances (sickness allowance, parental allowance, re- habilitation allowance and special care al- lowance) are raised to the same level as labour market support, in which case the allowances will increase by EUR 80.50 per month. The cost impact of the increase for the central government is approximately EUR 21 20 million on an annual basis. EUR 4.4 mil- lion is allocated in net terms to cover the costs of removing the 55-day qualifying pe- riod for sickness allowance. The criteria for young people’s vocational re- habilitation will be eased to support the stud- ies and employment of young people in a dif- ficult position. In addition, a rehabilitation allowance will be paid as participation income to young people in vocational rehabilitation for the entire period of the rehabilitation de- cision. An additional appropriation of EUR 3.6 million is allocated in 2019 for the change. A total increase of EUR 1.5 million is allo- cated for youth workshop activities and for outreach youth work. The guaranteed pension is increased by ap- proximately EUR 9 per month, which in- creases central government expenditure by EUR 10 million on an annual basis. New legislation will give front-line veterans the right to the same services supporting liv- ing at home to which disabled war veterans are already entitled. A total sum of EUR 40 million be allocated to this in 2019. EUR 1.2 million is allocated for developing and organising food aid activities nationally for people in need of special Support. 5.3 Local government finances and the regional government reform The central government funds the opera- tions of municipalities with central govern- ment transfers and discretionary government transfers provided through the government aid system. The central government can- not influence the expenditure in municipal- ities directly; this is governed by legislation enacted by the Parliament and the munic- ipalities’ own decisions. The local govern- ment finances programme and chapter 8 of the 2019 budget’s general strategy and out- look describe the state of local government finances and the impact of central govern- ment measures on local government finances in further detail. 5.3.1 Local government finances: rev- enue, expenditure and financial posi- tion In 2019, the revenue of the municipalities is expected to consist of tax revenue (55%), operating income (22%), central government transfers (20%) and other revenue (4%). It is estimated that 47% of municipalities’ ex- penditure will be allocated to personnel ex- pences, 32% to procurement of services and materials, 11% to investments and 9% to other expenditure. The distribution of mu- nicipalities’ revenue and expenditure is illus- trated in Diagram 10. Under the Government’s budgetary targets for local government finances, local govern- ment net lending (on a National Accounts basis) may not exceed -0.5 per cent of GDP in 2019. In the light of current forecasts, this target will be achieved in 2019. The deficit of the local government sector is estimated to be -0.5% of GDP and debt to be 9.1% in 2019. The development of the deficit and debt is illustrated in Diagram 11 and this 22 topic is discussed in more detail in Chapter 2.4 of the winter 2018 Economic Survey of the Ministry of Finance. Central government measures affect the rev- enue and expenditure of municipalities. The net impact of central government measures will weaken local government finances by ap- proximately EUR 254 million in 2019. The weakening is due above all to statutory ad- justment to the division of costs between the central government and municipalities, and the freezing of index adjustments under the Government Programme. The impacts are transferred to municipalities as changes, de- cided by the Parliament, to the tasks, opera- tions and funding of the municipalities. The most significant measures are the adjustment to the division of costs between central gov- ernment and municipalities as well as mea- sures reducing municipalities expenditure in accordance with Annex 6 of the Government Programme (e.g. centralisation of specialised medical care, revising the quality recommen- dation in services for the elderly, and devel- opment of informal and family care). The impact of central government measures on municipalities has been analysed in more de- tail in Chapter 8.3 of the general strategy and outlook of the budget proposal and in Chapter 2.2 of the local government finances programme. 5.3.2 Health, social services and re- gional government reform The entry into force of the regional govern- ment, health and social services reform is postponed until the beginning of 2021. The date of the first county elections will be deter- mined after Parliament has made its decisions on the legislation for the regional govern- ment, health and social services reform. The counties would be established immediately after the legislation enters into force and the county interim administrations would lead the preparation of the counties’ administra- tion and operations until the elected county councils begin their term of office. The re- sponsibility for the arrangement of health and social services and management of the du- ties of other administrative branches will be transferred to the counties at the beginning in 2021. Approximately EUR 211 million in central government budget financing is earmarked for preparations for the implementation of the reform in 2019. The financing will cover the costs of advance preparations and the interim administration, planning and imple- mentation of national information systems, and the establishment of the counties’ joint service centres. The financing will be used to realise regional and national change man- agement as well as preparations for the im- plementation required by the reform also in the Government. 23 6 Summary This publication examines the 2019 budget. The publication has been expanded to inc- lude an examination of sustainable develop- ment appropriations. The key objectives of the Government inc- lude bridging the sustainability gap in gene- ral government finances and increasing the employment rate. The goal is to bring living on debt to an end in 2021. The Government Programme includes different consolidation measures. The focus of taxation will be shif- ted from taxing labour and entrepreneurship towards environmentally and health motiva- ted taxation. Growth in the economy is expected to slow down in 2019. The unemployment rate is pro- jected to fall and the employment rate to ri- se. Due to population ageing, however, the- re is a considerable sustainability gap, i.e. an imbalance between revenue and expenditure, in general government finances in the long term. The 2019 budget totals approximately EUR 55.5 billion. The central government on-bud- get deficit is projected to amount to appro- ximately EUR 1.7 billion and central govern- ment debt is expected to rise to approxima- tely EUR 107 billion. The budget for 2019 includes investments in supporting employment, skills and research, preventing inequality, preparing the reform of regional government, health and social servi- ces, police and defence operations, agricultu- re, waterways protection and early childhood education. Unemployment benefit expenditu- re is expected to decline due to an improving employment situation. The 2019 budget will also be updated on the www.tutkibudjettia.fi website which allows the budget to be examined visually from dif- ferent perspectives. 24 7 Inquiries Budget Department Director General Hannu Mäkinen, tel. +358 2955 30330 Deputy Head of Budget Department Juha Majanen, tel. +358 2955 30247 Ministry of Finance Snellmaninkatu 1 A PO BOX 28, 00023 GOVERNMENT tel. +358 9 295 160 01 Budget review 2019. January 2019 Ministry of Finance publications 2019:5 ISSN 1797-9714 (zine) ISBN 978-952-251-986-3 (zine) 25 8 Reading instructions and printable version The budget review is a Mobile Zine HTML- 5-based publication also suitable for mobile devices. This digital publication is readable on all devices regardless of their operating system or screen size (computers, tablets, smartphones and TV receivers with a web browser). The content of the publication is automatically scaled to the currently active screen size. You can enlarge pictures and di- agrams to full screen size by clicking them. When reading the publication on your com- puter, you can easily move from one page to another using the keyboard arrow keys, and on a touch-screen device by swiping the screen to the right or left. Feedback How did you like our web publication? Please share your opinion with us at Julkaisutuotanto@vnk.fi. 26